Santa Fake

John Rhys-Davies

Jow

Judd Nelson

Seb

Heather Morris

Emily

Jeff Fahey

Jim

Tony Amendola

Father Estaban

Damian McGinty

Pat

Pancho Moler

Alowishus

Gary Farmer

Santa

Gavin White

Pushy Boy Dirk

Ryan O'Malley

Baby Pat

Wyatt Mortenson

Fred

Rebekah Wiggins

Bar Maid

Scott Clark

Piano Man

Charlene Fox

Bus Ticket Agent

Soledad St. Hilaire

Mrs. Ortega

Ryan Begay

Officer Ryan

Esodie Geiger

FBI Agent Martinez

Elias Gallegos

FBI Agent 2

Sylka Feliciano

Mall Photographer Elf

Alli Valdez

Restaurant Hostess (as Allison Valdez)

Giovanna A. Hinojosa

Flamenco Dancer (as Giovanna Hinojosa)

Mario febres

Flamenco Guitarist

Mike Salazar

Vincente (as Mike Salazar)

Robbie Marie

Maggie

Otgadahe Whitman-Fox

Social Worker

Javier Gonzales

Donations Bucket Bell Ringer (as Mayor Javier Gonzales)

Celine R. Lopez

Cleaning Lady (as Celine Rosario Lopez)

Juliet Rose Serrato

Shopper Woman

Stephen Aquila

Mall Shopper/FBI Agent (uncredited)

Stephen Conn

Mall Patron (uncredited)

Matthew J Ellis

Party Parent/Mall Shopper (uncredited)

Nicolai Kabana

Plaza Goer (uncredited)

Kyle Pierson

Mall Shopper/Party Goer (uncredited)

Michael Slusher

Mall Visitor (uncredited)

Rafael Velásquez

Bar Patron (uncredited)

Luke Whoriskey

John (uncredited)